FREE SHIPPING with $75 Purchase - or - FREE with the L.L.Bean Mastercard 
‹ Back to L.L.Bean Men's Stonington Plain-Toe Oxford Shoes With Water-Resistant Leather
Customer Reviews for L.L.Bean Men's Stonington Plain-Toe Oxford Shoes With Water-Resistant Leather
View Product DetailsCustomer Reviews
What customers say:
The Stonington Oxford shoes are generally well-received by customers. The majority find them to be very comfortable, suitable for all-day wear, and of high quality in terms of leather and construction. Many describe the shoes as stylish and classic in appearance. While a few customers experienced minor issues like laces coming undone or the fit feeling slightly too wide, the overall consensus is that these are excellent, durable, and well-made shoes.
AI Generated from customer reviews.286 Reviews
Sort:
Verified Purchase
September 3, 2026
Not that comfortable
Returned the shoes. Nice looking, but not comfortable.
Was this helpful?
00
Verified Purchase
September 3, 2026
Well made
Nice looking shoe, I get complimented all the time from my daughter.
Was this helpful?
00
September 1, 2026
Nice shoes exept soles wore out too quickly
Size Purchased: 11
Used for: Casual or Every Day
I bought these to wear in the office only. The top looks great still but the soles are worn through after a year.
Response from L.L.Bean
September 5, 2026
By L.L.Bean Customer Service Team
We're sorry to learn these shoes did not hold up as you expected. We want you to be satisfied with how our products perform. You do have a full year to return an item to us, and you are welcome to return items that have been worn. Get in touch if you need assistance with a return.
Vermont
Was this helpful?
20
August 19, 2026
They started out great….
Size Purchased: 12
Used for: Casual or Every Day
I bought these shoes about a month and a half ago. I liked them. They took a little breaking in but not significant. Then today I noticed the soul was coming away from the shoe at
Haverhill
Was this helpful?
10
August 10, 2026
Great Shoe for Foot Pain
Size Purchased: 13
Used for: Travel, Casual or Every Day
I suffer from Plantar Factitious and I needed a pair of shoes that were water resistant. I choose this pair because they are LL Bean quality, they haves removable insoles and can s
Utah
Was this helpful?
22
Verified Purchase
June 27, 2026
Great buy
Size Purchased: 13
Used for: Casual or Every Day
Well priced, very simple and functional shoe, my everyday work shoes now
Irvine Ca
Was this helpful?
00
Verified Purchase
June 18, 2026
So Close!
I like the style of these shoes; the sneaker-bottomed casual dress oxfords through a Bean-rugged lens is perhaps a hybrid too far for this old-timer, but these manage those narrow
Was this helpful?
12
Verified Purchase
June 7, 2026
Great shoes
Size Purchased: 9 1/2
Used for: Casual or Every Day
Very comfortable shoes and they look great with jeans and chinos.
Providence RI
Was this helpful?
00
Verified Purchase
May 29, 2026
Work Shoes
Size Purchased: 9
My husband wears these shoes for work in his auto repair shop. They hold up well and are comfortable with arch supports.
Wiscasset, Maine
Was this helpful?
10
Verified Purchase
May 17, 2026
Great shoe
Comfortable and good fit. Laces keep coming undone but this seems to happen with various shoes regardless of brand.
Was this helpful?
00
Verified Purchase
May 14, 2026
Nice shoes
I really like the shoes! They’re very comfortable straight out of box and they look nice too . These are my new casual shoes to go too . Will definitely purchase again
Was this helpful?
00
Verified Purchase
May 6, 2026
Very impressed with the level of comfort
Size Purchased: 14
Used for: Casual or Every Day
Did not expect these shoes to be as comfortable as they are. Very satisfied with this purchase
Was this helpful?
00
Verified Purchase
April 24, 2026
Meh-so-so
Not as comfortable for walking as I hoped, especially for the price.
Was this helpful?
00
April 23, 2026
Soles wore out very quickly
Size Purchased: 9 1/2
Used for: Casual or Every Day
The soles wore down with just a year or two of use. Good support. Hard to find a service to resolve the shoes.
Worcester MA
Was this helpful?
11
Verified Purchase
April 18, 2026
As Expected
I was looking for a quality casual shoe with a soft sole. These are quality built with a nice soft soul and incredibly comfortable.
Was this helpful?
00
Verified Purchase
April 9, 2026
Comfortable out of the box.
Size Purchased: 11
Used for: Casual or Every Day
Nice casual shoe to ware with jeans. Fits true to size. Good cushioning and very comfortable.
Webster NY
Was this helpful?
00
Verified Purchase
March 20, 2026
I bought these because I was looking for a rugged type of shoe that could be comfortable to my feet, warm, and dry. I guess 2 out of 3 isn't bad, and I'm not sure its your fault,
Was this helpful?
00
Verified Purchase
February 15, 2026
Comfortable
Been very comfortable shoes since day 1, great for everyday wear.
Was this helpful?
30
Verified Purchase
February 15, 2026
Great shoes!
Size Purchased: 9 1/2
Used for: Travel, Casual or Every Day, Hiking
I bought the shoe four week ago. They are comfortable and easy to wear. I plan to buy another pair soon!
New York
Was this helpful?
10
Verified Purchase
January 20, 2026
High quality workmanship
Size Purchased: 9
Used for: Casual or Every Day
Purchased for my husband. He appreciates the comfort , and style.
Was this helpful?
10
Viewing 1 - 20 of 286
‹ Back to L.L.Bean Men's Stonington Plain-Toe Oxford Shoes With Water-Resistant Leather